Illegal Poaching in Africa

Profile picture of
gy_cormac2

View Profile All Posts

Illegal poaching and trade of endangered animals has been a huge issue in Africa for many years. Even today, despite great efforts by African wildlife authorities and environmental groups, the killing goes on. Earlier this year, over 1,200 tusks were discovered in Tanzania, a sign that the situation is still nowhere near where it should be. It is therefore understandable that conservation groups such as IFAW should be outraged at the recent proposals being put forward by governments for a limited legal trade in certain animal products. However, as is so often the case, the argument is a complicated one, and it’s difficult to judge what is best. The two most poignant cases concern the elephant and the rhino, both species that were severely threatened during the poaching era of the 1980s.

The Elephant Issue

Elephant poaching

The elephant population of South Africa has grown steadily thanks to the great efforts employed by conservation groups and wildlife authorities in Africa. Nevertheless massive numbers of elephants are killed every year illegally to feed the ever-hungry black market in ivory.

Recently the South African government made a proposal concerning the sale of ivory and elephant hides stockpiled by their national parks through natural mortality and problem animal control. The money from these sales would be put back into their parks and would help fund activities such as elephant management programmes, control of illegal hunting of elephants, and creating more and larger protected areas for the elephants to be re-established in. The items sold would come from legitimate sources – materials seized from illegal traders would not be included in the trades. The proponents of this proposal claim it would provide a sustainable way of maintaining the conservation efforts of the African elephant.

Conservationists take a different view. They warn that opening up a legal ivory trade would encourage ‘the proliferation of illegal activities such as poaching, and thus associated illegal markets.’ They reason that creating a legal ivory market would serve only to support the growth of current markets in poached ivory. This would undermine the efforts that the governments are attempting to support through the proposed legal market. Instead, the groups suggest that the governments invest in creating a healthy eco-tourism industry, which would benefit everyone, both financially and ecologically.

Rhino Reservations

The same debate is rife over the protected Rhinos of South Africa – the black rhino, whose overall population in Africa has decreased by 83% since 1980, and the white rhino, whose numbers had been reduced to just 20 at the turn of the century. Again there are two opinions regarding the market for these animals’ assets.

Some believe that trade in rhino horn and other by-products should be made legal, as it would in fact encourage people to breed them for commercial purposes, which would allow the wild populations to thrive. Making it legal and more widely available would also decrease its value, and lessen the attraction for poaching and trading in the substances, as they become less precious. A legal market would be much easier to control and regulate, and the money gained could go towards funding further conservation efforts.

Again the argument has two sides, and conservationists believe that such a market would be disastrous in terms of its effects on the rhino population and the popularity of poaching. Similar to the proposals concerning ivory and other elephant derived materials, the groups insist that once a legal market is opened, it would become almost impossible to control or regulate the illegal trade through poaching of the animals.

The proposals in question primarily involve down listing the animals in the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) Appendix from Appendix I – whereby trade in products or live animals is illegal – to Appendix II, which would allow for trade in live animals, leather goods and ‘the non-commercial trade of sporting trophies’. The move is opposed by Kenya and India, who both maintain an anti-trade stance.

To some it seems a difficult choice but the benefits and costs are clear and poignant. Most arguable is the point that ivory and rhino horn are products which should be removed from the world market altogether. No-one needs them for survival, and those who benefit from the sales could benefit equally from a developed and established eco-tourism industry which would bring wealth and business interests to the countries while benefiting and supporting the wildlife and local people. Yet R25.91 million worth of ivory and hide stockpiles remain in Kruger National Park in South Africa. Should these be used to support further developments of conservational programmes, at the risk of worsening the threat of death to the very animals they protect? Or should they be left untouched in support of the zero-quota principle, at the loss of the precious financial help which their sale could provide for the cause? Let us know what you think.

Check out these top conservation projects

Search

Marine Conservation, Mozambique

from £1850

14 - 112 days

Mozambique

Live on the beach and join a world-class research team in Southern Mozambique, one of the best diving locations in...

Marine Conservation in South Africa

from £1295

14 - 70 days

South Africa

Learn to dive or improve whilst contributing to turtle, shark, potato bass and whale research in Sodwana Bay; one of...

Madagascar Marine Conservation

from £895

7 - 140 days

Madagascar

Dive in some of the least explored marine sites in the world, helping further the research and protection of these...

Madagascar Wildlife Conservation

from £795

7 - 180 days

Madagascar

Discover, monitor and assess the huge variety of Madagascar's exotic and rare species as you trek through remote regions of...

Wildlife Conservation Adventure

from £595

7 - 140 days

Madagascar

This project's aims are to contribute to the current understanding of the local environment and help monitor the spectacular array...

Rhino & Elephant Conservation

from £620

7 - 56 days

Zimbabwe

A unique conservation programme, dedicated to the conservation and protection of the endangered black rhino and African elephant. Play your...

Marine Conservation

from £950

7 - 90 days

South Africa

Work closely with marine biologists monitoring and conserving Great White sharks, seals, whales and other marine life.

Madagascar Marine Conservation

from £895

7 - 140 days

Madagascar

Escape to Madagascar – the magical island which is home to some of the world's most spectacular and least explored...

Namibia Desert Elephant Conservation

from £995

14 - 84 days

Namibia

Join an award winning elephant conservation team to help protect and research the desert elephants.

Madagascar Lemur & Conservation

from £895

14 - 70 days

Madagascar

Help to protect the endangered habitats of unique Madagascan species including lemurs working alongside international research staff in a beautiful...

Search

Ultimate Africa

from £4759

Spanning nine countries, this journey is full of diverse cultures, abundant wildlife, spectacular landscapes, stunning beaches, and loads of adventure....

Madrid to Venice

from £4295

Elaborate architecture and exceptional cuisine, legendary landscapes and live history on the streets – western and central Europe is a...

Dunes, Deltas & Falls Discoverer

from £2599

This 18-day journey through four African countries hits the highlights and is perfect for the adventurer who wants to discover...

Kenya Expedition – The Last Northern White Rhinos

from £1990

Join Intrepid on a special journey to Ol Pejeta Conservancy, Kenya, to spend time with the last remaining northern white...

Kenya & Tanzania Camping Safari

from £3149

Led by a certified safari guide, this 14-day tour will bring you to the famous wildlife habitats of both Kenya...

Explore Kruger & Victoria Falls

from £1817

Enjoy a nine-day highlights tour of South Africa and Zimbabwe. Go on safari in the Greater Kruger area, spotting and...

Kruger Experience – Lodge (5 days)

from £820

Embark on a thrilling journey into the vast, game-filled Kruger National Park. Head out on game drives to spot lions,...

Best of East Africa

from £2176

Find the best of East Africa on this Intrepid adventure as you traverse across Kenya and into Tanzania. Discover the...

Discover Namibia & Victoria Falls

from £2499

Go on an epic 12-day adventure in Namibia that includes two days on the Zimbabwean side of Victoria Falls. From...

Gorilla Trek Independent Adventure

from £1359

The ultimate primate experience, trek through local villages and lush rainforests with the breathtaking reward of finding yourself in the...

Find more articles about amazing animals

Search
[contact-form-7 id="4" title="Contact form 1"]