Lonely Planet travel forum closes

2nd Jan 2013
Written by: Macca Sherifi

Lonely Planet travel forum closes

BBC shuts down Lonely Planet’s Thorn Tree travel forum

The commercial arm of the BBC has shut down its hugely popular forum for backpackers and travellers because “uncomfortable themes” were being discussed.

BBC Worldwide spokesman Philip Fleming told the Daily Mail “offensive swear words” and “bad language” had been detected, forcing them to “reassess” how they carried out the moderation of their user comments.

On 26th December, Lonely Planet’s Thorn Tree travel forum released the following statement: “We’re sorry but the Thorn Tree forum is temporarily closed as we’ve discovered instances of inappropriate language and themes. Until we’re confident all rogue posts have been identified and appropriate action taken we feel we have no option but to temporarily close the forum as a precautionary measure.

“We’re actively working on this throughout the holiday period – please bear with us.

According to newspapers in Australia an unnamed source from the Lonely Planet site said the decision to shut the forum was “all about Jimmy Savile”.

“They discovered that if you looked for terms like ‘paedophile’ or ‘child prostitution’, you got Thorn Tree hits,” the source told the Sydney Morning Herald.

“The hits are mostly discussions of current events or pointless stuff that would have been moderated, like ‘Barney the dinosaur is a big purple paedophile’. However, someone found a thread about ‘what’s the age of consent in Mexico?’ That really set them off.

“They went into full, freak-out, panic attack mode.”

Lonely Planet closes Thorn Tree travel forum

A number of users who use the Thorn Tree forum went online to express their anger at its sudden closure.

One traveller, Dustin Dolatowski, tweeted: “You couldn’t have picked a worse time for closing the Thorn Tree forum.”

Another, Bruce Taylor, wrote: “The state of Lonely Planet is depressing. Shutting Thorn Tree is the latest eg of BBC clearly not understanding what they bought.”

Cormac Scanlan, chief operating officer at gapyear.com, said: “Messageboard forums have been the most popular place for internet users to meet online to discuss the topics they are passionate about since the late 90s, and travel has been one of the most popular. Like Lonely Planet, for over a decade we’ve facilitated the realtime interactions of so many inspiring travellers on the gapyear.com messageboards, watched their excitement as they plan their trips and enabled them to help each other through trials and tribulations.

“Members of online travel communities may move on as sites shut down or interests change, but the sum total of their past interactions make for a massive, impartial and invaluable resource to travellers. The loss of any part of this large online travel community is felt greatly.”

Do you think the BBC is overreacting or do you think there should be stricter guidelines to travel forums? Drop a comment below.

Also, let us know what you think by coming over to our travel forum and get talking to your fellow travellers on the message boards.


International Business Internship In Indonesia

from £1035

30 days


Indonesia is an excellent destination in Asia to pursue and undergo an international business internship.

International Business Internship In Japan

from £1770

30 days


One of the most desired places in the world to work, Japan is an ideal destination to pursue an international...

Aegean Marine Conservation Internship in Greece

from £810

28 - 168 days


Take part in year-round internships in Samos Island, Greece. Programs begin from just 4 weeks - gain insight and experience...

Teaching in Zanzibar

from £939

14 - 84 days


Located in a village right on the coast of Zanzibar, this project gives you the chance to assist with teaching,...

Wildlife Law Internship in Malawi

from £1

30 - 365 days

Enhance your knowledge and gain invaluable practical experience in an exciting field of law

Namibia – Conservation and Adventure Intertwined

from £1850

30 - 30 days


Program includes: A unique mix of conservation and community projects with wildlife safaris, whitewater rafting, trekking and mountain biking.

Intern in PR & Marketing in New York

from £4963

42 - 180 days

United States of America

Are you interested in PR & Marketing? We have amazing roles for you in Global Capital of Culture and Commerce,...

Highlights Of Spain & Portugal

from £423

7 days

Portugal, Spain

A 7-day jam-packed tour giving you a quick highlights experience of Spain and Portugal, from the main cities to the...

Gap Year China

from £1120

28 - 180 days


Learn Mandarin, gain work experience and travel.

Short-Term University Study in New Zealand

from £7000

120 days

New Zealand

Tester semester allows you to enroll at a New Zealand university for just one term. If you are trying to...


Ultimate Italy: Winter

From the delightful small towns of Umbria to Venice's splendour, this is an adventure for those looking to indulge in...

Kenya & Tanzania Safari Under Canvas

from £5350

This trip delivers adventure and comfort in equal measures. Travel through these welcoming nations, past stunning scenery, tiny farming villages...

Backroads & Highlands of Peru

from £999

Get off the beaten path in the highlands of Peru and discover stunning mountain scenery and remote cities few tourists...

Balkan Trail

from £791

Join us as we venture into the very heart of the stunning Balkans and encounter a region whose fascinatingly varied...

Costa Rica Family Holiday

from £3200

Experience the drama of Costa Rica’s landscapes, the real flavours of its culture and cuisine and uncover the country’s adventurous...

Quest of the Gods

Whether you’re scanning the canopy for wildlife from the comfort of our intimate and exclusive G Lodge Amazon or trekking...

Kenya Family Safari

from £1365

Swap the hubbub of Kenya's capital for the calls of flamingos, zebras and rhinos as you journey from Nairobi to...

Hogmanay 5 Day

from £599

Head to Edinburgh for the world-famous Hogmanay New Year celebrations and take part in this festival to rival all festivals....

G Lodge Amazon & Camping – 5 Day Independent Adventure

Located on the Tambopata River in the Peruvian Amazon, our exclusive G Lodge Amazon is comfortable and intimate. Enjoy excursions...

Kruger, Falls & Botswana Safari

It's never too late to experience an authentic African safari - especially if it's right in the heart of Southern...

[contact-form-7 id="4" title="Contact form 1"]